San Mateo's Hidden Gems
Hidden Gems in San Mateo: The Best Neighborhoods You’ve Never Heard Of
If you’re reading this, you just found one of the best-kept secrets in all of the Bay Area.
San Mateo has way more to offer than you might think. From peaceful parks to stunning views, there are a ton of neighborhoods that deserve way more attention than they’re getting.
If you’re thinking about living in San Mateo or even just exploring what San Mateo, CA, is all about, you’ve come to the right place.
Welcome to the Top Hidden Gem Neighborhoods in San Mateo - just make sure you keep these to yourself!
1. Hillsdale The Lanes: A Quiet Neighborhood with Big Perks
You might not have heard much about Hillsdale The Lanes, but as soon as you see it for the first time, you’ll wonder how it’s stayed under the radar for so long.
This neighborhood is right north of Hillsdale Boulevard and east of El Camino, and it feels like its own little bubble of peace. The cul-de-sacs? A go-to for families.
What’s There to Love about The Lanes?
Super family-friendly, with parks at nearly every turn.
Homes range from $1.8 million to $2.6 million - more affordable compared to nearby areas.
Mostly ranch-style homes with attached garages, giving you practical layouts and a cozy feel.
If you're considering San Mateo real estate, this could be an amazing neighborhood to start your search. It’s quiet but still close to everything you need.
2. Parkside & Shoreview: Affordable Living with Bay Views
Looking for a more budget-friendly option? Parkside and Shoreview are perfect if you're not ready to dive into the high prices of the more well-known neighborhoods.
This is one of the places you need to check out if you’re looking for those sweet waterfront views, but more on that later. The area is located just east of 101 and south of Coyote Point - and if we’re being honest here, it gives you a lot of bang for your buck.
Why Parkside & Shoreview Stand Out:
Prices range from $1.1 million to $1.7 million, making it one of the most affordable options, even with the killer waterfront views.
You’re right near the Bay Trail, a more than ideal spot for morning jogs or weekend bike rides.
Seal Point Park is a local favorite for dog walks, and it also has lots to offer if you want to look out for even more stunning views.
It’s true that the area is built on a compacted landfill, so you’ll want to consider liquefaction zones. However, the value here is unmatched if you’ve been looking for a starter home here in San Mateo.
3. Laurelwood: A Scenic Hillside Gem
Living on the waterfront is not your only option around here if views are your thing, and this neighborhood is there to prove it.
Laurelwood is just south of Highway 92 and east of 280, and it is perfect if you want that extra bit of elevation—and, of course, the peace and quiet that come with it.
So, What Makes Laurelwood Special?
Homes range from $1.5 million to $3 million, which is pretty fitting for a big range of budgets.
Quick and easy access to 280 for stress-free commuting, especially great if you work outside of town.
Close to Crystal Springs Shopping Village, so you’re never far from any amenities you might need.
All in all, if you’re into hillside living without the crazy price tags, Laurelwood is just for you.
4. Beresford Park: A Family-Centric Neighborhood
If there’s a neighborhood that will always stay on top of every family’s list, it’s Beresford Park.
With basketball courts, skate parks, a community garden, and a newly upgraded playground, there’s always something to do around here, and that explains a lot of its charm. It’s located just south of Highway 92, which gives you easy access to the entire city.
More Reasons Why Beresford Park is a Hit:
Homes range from $1.4 million to $3.8 million, giving options for every budget.
Super close to Hillsdale Shopping Center, which is another great place to check out with your family and for your kids to have fun.
Beresford Park itself has tons of options for entertainment, and it even hosts its own community garden.
There are tons of park options, which is also perfect if you and your family want to embrace that outdoorsy lifestyle.
If your family has been wanting to settle down in San Mateo, Beresford Park is a hidden gem that’s still reasonably priced compared to nearby areas like Baywood. It’s a great place to consider if you want your kids to make the most of their childhood.
5. The Highlands: Mid-Century Modern Charm
Love a good mid-century modern home? The Highlands has some of the coolest architecture around, thanks to one of the Peninsula’s most iconic developers: Joseph Eichler.
If you’re into big windows, open floor plans, and that classic 1960s style, you’ll feel right at home here - and you’ll have an amazing house to show it.
What Else Makes the Highlands Stand Out?
Mid-century homes with floor-to-ceiling windows and radiant floor heating.
Home prices range from $2 million to $4.2 million, so it’s a bit on that higher end, but it’s also worth the price if you appreciate the iconic architecture.
Highlands Recreation Center is right here; it has its own pool and other community
perks that you’d definitely want to keep near your home.
If you’re navigating San Mateo's housing market with functionality and style in mind, The Highlands is a must-see.
5. The Highlands: Mid-Century Modern Charm
Love a good mid-century modern home? The Highlands has some of the coolest architecture around, thanks to one of the Peninsula’s most iconic developers: Joseph Eichler.
If you’re into big windows, open floor plans, and that classic 1960s style, you’ll feel right at home here - and you’ll have an amazing house to show it.
What Else Makes the Highlands Stand Out?
Mid-century homes with floor-to-ceiling windows and radiant floor heating.
Home prices range from $2 million to $4.2 million, so it’s a bit on that higher end, but it’s also worth the price if you appreciate the iconic architecture.
Highlands Recreation Center is right here; it has its own pool and other community
perks that you’d definitely want to keep near your home.
If you’re navigating San Mateo's housing market with functionality and style in mind, The Highlands is a must-see.
6. Sunnybrae: Central and Charming
If you’re looking for a neighborhood that’s close to downtown, Sunnybrae might be the perfect spot.
It’s located just west of Highway 101 and north of Highway 92. It has a mix of cozy, ranch-style homes and some newer two-story builds. It’s a smaller, tight-knit neighborhood that’s great if you want some suburban comfort with easy access to city life.
Why Sunnybrae is a Gem:
Homes here range from about $1.2 million to $2.2 million, which is relatively affordable for San Mateo real estate.
You can walk downtown pretty easily without having to get the car out, meaning all the shops, restaurants, and cafes are right at your fingertips.
Streets like Birch and Grant are particularly charming, and with Sunnybrae Elementary and nearby Borel Middle School, it’s great for families with young kids.
It may be small, but Sunnybrae packs a punch with its location and appeal. If you want a slice of suburban life that’s still close to the action, this could be the neighborhood for you.
7. Edgewater Isle: Lagoon-Front Haven
If you thought your waterfront options ended at Shoreline and Lakeview, you were wrong.
Edgewater Isle is definitely a part of San Mateo, but it sometimes manages to feel more like Foster City with its serene lagoon-front townhomes. This is the place to be if you love being near the water without paying Foster City prices.
Even More Perks Within Edgewater Isle:
Townhomes range from $1 million to $1.7 million, which means exactly what you’re thinking of: Affordable waterfront living right here in the Bay Area!
You also get direct access to the Bay Trail for biking, walking, and taking in the views, which I’m sure lots of frequent joggers and cyclists will appreciate.
Close to Bridgepointe Shopping Center, so essentials are always nearby.
There’s a reason why this is one of San Mateo’s best-kept secrets. If you want a mix of tranquility and convenience, check this one out - but don’t tell too many people about it!
From Hidden Gem to Perfect Home
These neighborhoods all have something to offer whether you’re a first-time buyer, looking for a second home, or want to familiarize yourself with San Mateo’s real estate.
So, if any of these caught your eye, make sure you get in touch with an experienced agent as soon as possible! The more local knowledge, the higher your shot is at finding the perfect home you’ve always dreamed of.
You can reach out to hello@burlingameproperties.com, or text 650-822-7088 to learn more about your options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the commute like from San Mateo to other parts of the Bay Area?
San Mateo has a killer position right between San Francisco and Silicon Valley, with easy access to major freeways like 101 and 280. Depending on where you live, you can reach most major job hubs within 20 to 40 minutes.
Also public transportation is also a solid option, with Caltrain stations nearby!
How are the public schools in San Mateo?
San Mateo schools are generally strong, with some neighborhoods like Beresford Park and Laurelwood being zoned for highly rated schools.
You’ll also find a range of private schools in the area, but most families find the public school options to be more than great.
Are homes in San Mateo affordable?
“Affordable” is relative when it comes to the Bay Area. You have neighborhoods like Parkside and Shoreview, which offer more starter-level prices (around $1.1 million to $1.7 million). Then, you have the more established or luxurious neighborhoods like The Highlands or Laurelwood, which can go up to $4 million or more.
With all that said, compared to areas like San Francisco or Palo Alto, San Mateo can definitely get you a lot more for your money - just trust your agent to negotiate the best price for your budget!
